Although the women of the United States are confined within the narrow circle of domestic life, and their situation is, in some respects, one of extreme dependence, I have nowhere seen woman occupying a loftier position; and if I were asked... in which I have spoken of so many important things done by Americans, to what the singular prosperity and growing strength of that people ought mainly to be attributed, I should reply, To the superiority of their women.

--Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy in America

Saturday, February 28, 2015

Churchianity Makes Me Sick

First off, there is becoming apparent, even to unbelievers, of a huge divide between a New Testament church fueled by the Holy Spirit and this counterfeit that is driving actual believers out of church. Spurgeon predicted this all over 100 years in his sermon: Churchianity vs. Christianity. 

Whenever Churchianity has ruled, revelry and wantonness have been winked at, so long as saints' days, sacraments, and priests have been regarded. God's law is nothing to the high church, so long as church forms are scrupulously and ostentatiously observed. We should see maypoles erected and danced around on a Sunday afternoon within a year, if Churchianity had its way; the Book of Sports would be revived, and the evening of the Lord's day would be dedicated to the devil. Leave the church open, observe saints' days, decorate the altar, sing "Hymns Ancient and Modern," put on tagrags, and all goes smoothly with Churchianity: preach the gospel, and denounce sin, and straightway there is no small stir.
Can you disagree with any of that? Of course he's calling out the Anglicans, but one could also apply the same to Hawaiian shirt preachers and the forms that they all follow. Wantonness surely has been winked at in our time, just as the Bible prophesied about the ear ticklers that would be prominent in the last days.(2 Tim 4:3)

When I am looking for a church, I always strive to find the most Bible-believing one I possibly can. Even so, I have witnessed some of the craziest/sick stuff in church that I would never have thought possible. I've seen my Sunday School teacher's mug shot on TV while getting my five year old ready for kindergarten. He had a baby-sitter club going on in the youth group. I've visited the church of a close relative whose pastor was busted by the FBI for arranging dates with middle school boys via the internet. I can't believe I shook his hand - yuck. I've seen a middle aged woman who was supposed to be keeping the church's records literally run down the hall and screech out the parking lot when I asked for them. This only scratches the surface of what I've seen at church in the last 15 years. I could write a book, but it would be like Peyton Place.

And if anything like the above happens near or around you, you're not supposed to talk about it, because that's gossip and we don't want to spread unpleasantness do we? If you get hurt in these situations, just pray that God will help you suck it up and be quiet about it. Whatever you do, don't make waves, don't confront anyone because that is division. Remember your public school training about getting along, right? Well, the Bible actually tells us differently. I had to employ a Matthew 18 confrontation to resolve a situation in church before and it works beautifully. But the thing is, you have to be willing to go all the way with it -even before the church, which can be kind of scary. I realize now to fix the problems in that church, I may have had to do a couple more such confrontations to get the leaven out. Why me? Because no one else would and I just couldn't take it anymore.

One thing I've noticed in Paul's letters is that he usually either begins or ends with calling someone out on the carpet. He lists their name for us to read today and tells that church to mark and avoid that person because of bad theology or some other major problem. These verses never get preached on.

This is in large part due to the fact that people are "running to and fro" (Dan 12:4)   Throughout most of human history, ordinary folk did not travel far from where they were born, giving you roots and your family a reputation. You couldn't just move to another town and start all over again easily. The early church was a community of believers in a fixed area and except for missionary types like Paul and his cohorts, they weren't moving around every 3-5 years as is now common nowadays. A pastor told me that once upon a time in countryside America, churches had sergeants-at-arms and church discipline was a serious thing. You went to the church you could walk or ride your buggy to, so this church "choice" phenomenon wasn't a factor in how the church operated.

Fast forward to the motor car era and now your choices of churches opened up quite a bit. Pastor too dry at your family church? Well, just go a few miles over to the next church, it only takes about 10 minutes. And so it began. With all the moving around, people became a lot less accountable. Whereas before, you lived your whole life in the same community of people, now just as your new church gets to know you, you might be transferred away or choose to go somewhere else. It's hard to gauge spiritual growth of someone in these circumstances. So we're left with this consumerist church as Spurgeon describes with the same introductory to Christianity pap that bores to tears those of us who have actually read our Bible through more than once. (Yes, we're the few, but proud - am I right or what?)

All this moving around creates a perfect storm where false teaching and chaos can breed. There's nothing new under the sun, however. Going back to Paul's letters, we see that the early church had issues as well. The difference is that Paul addressed them publicly so that the church would not get led into error. There are a few today who are filling that role, so I thought I'd share some discernment sites that I enjoy that keep tabs on error in the church - particularly the New Age/emergent/contemplative spirituality that is/will be a precursor to the Antichrist one-world religious system. aka coexist.

From the Lighthosue
Noise of Thunder 
The Berean Call
Understand the Times
Fight the Good Fight
Worldview Weekend
The Lion of Judah
Kjos Ministries
Spiritual Sounding Board
FBC Jax Watchdogs
Musuem of Idolatry - A Little Leaven

Disclaimer: (Because most people can't do critical thinking) I do not necessarily share all the viewpoints of those sites linked, because I'm not a mind-numbed robot.

So anyway, I see two different camps in Churchianity: the seeker-sensitive feel-goods and the hard-core reformed types as personified by John McArthur (who denies the blood atonement-yikes). It is the dialectic at work- you have these choices and no others. Reformed churches are becoming popular as an alternative to the Rick Warren model. Both turn into a works-based system. In the former, you give your all to their organization, I won't call it a church. In the later, their Lordship Salvation is really a very Catholic understanding of grace, making one think that their "reformation" was not complete, but that's a post for another day.


  1. Good to see you up and running. Your piece left me with a couple of thoughts. Here in Boise we have a guy, Matt Slick, who addresses all of this heresy and actually takes on atheists. Although his ego is the size of New Hampshire- he is a blast to listen to. He debates atheists and members of the kinds of churches you are talking about and he has hate mail fridays. He takes the strictest view literally- if it doesn't say so in the Bible- it's heresy. I listen to him every day 3-4 PM on 94.1. His website is where you will find everything about this guy. Worth a look.

    Secondly RM, and this is going to wax rather philosophically, people are just sheep. They don't even think about issues like Churchiality v Christianity. They don't know a divide even exists. They simply go about their business, attend church, and then go out and continue to be the same self serving, conflict avoiding, judgmental people they have always been. I know a gal here in Boise who attends church every week and honest- if I asked her why she went- I don't think she could tell me.

    Thanks for writing and wading into that cesspool at the Ron Paul site. have always enjoyed reading your writing.


  2. Thanks Brian. I thought with the internet hoo-doo going on, I'd better make the best of my blog before they come take me away.

    I'll definitely have to check that guy out. Sounds like my kind of radio - the kind that makes housework go faster.

    I've always been regarded as an intelligent person by my peers, and I try to be careful not to come off as arrogant or haughty. But lordy, it's getting hard. I know of the general human condition. I know that if you tell them this stuff, they'll just look at you blankly and go about their business. In person, I usually don't bother with this stuff unless I'm motivated with the Holy Ghost or the person I'm talking to seems receptive to the info.
    Thanks for checking in, that makes writing worth it when someone out there reads it!

    Happy blogging!

  3. I disagree with your premise that freedom of movement is to blame for the sinfulness of the modern church. The church has always been screwed up if you know church history. Its just now with the Internet, its more well known. Also, now, you aren't forced by government to go to any church at all, so people feel free to post about it on the Internet, which is what makes it more well known! Remember, NOT ONE BOOK FROM ANCIENT TIMES WAS BY A REGULAR PERSON. All literature in ancient times comes from the elites. There were no blogs. So all these stories of the glorious past, the golden age, back in the day when everything was perfect, is all FAKE NEWS made up by the elites of the past. Nothing has changed. As Solomon says, "There is nothing new under the sun; what has been is what will be."

    1. Yes, I see where you are coming from. I was focusing on the American Church and the breakdown of community that has thereby caused a rapid acceleration in the commercialization and professionalization of church.

      Church is a living body of Christians, not an institution. So I agree that the institution claiming to be church for ages past is screwed up and not the true ekklesia mentioned in the NT.

      I would argue that when mobility was more limited, the churches that gathered were closer to the ekklesia ideal and just had a log cabin or simple church building around them. The building actually might have served the group, but now the group serves the building. That's the point I think I was trying to make- breakdown of community makes it hard to minister to one another. Thanks for commenting!


Related Posts with Thumbnails